Muslim Contestations over Islam and the State Relationship: A Critical Appraisal


  • Showkat Ahmad Wagay Department of Islamic Studies, Aligarh Muslim University, India



Muslim secularists, Caliphate, Islamists, Private Islam


Recent years have seen a proliferation of academic writing on the relationship of Islam and state from both the Muslims and non-Muslim academicians alike. Mostly, this academic writing used the trend of Islamism as a peg to ponder about the relationship of Islam and the state. The advocates of this trend hold the belief that the state is the nerve centre of Islam. They believed that Islam is a holistic religion and denies the separability of religion from politics and considers political power as an indispensable mechanism to achieve the ends of Islam. They posit Islamic governance as an authentic and correct form of polity. The other trend claims that Islam is primarily silent on the issue of the “state,” and that notions of an “Islamic state” or caliphate are dictatorial and antithetical to traditional Islam, though Islamic values can inform the individual in their role as a citizen within a democratic state. They proposed an alternative conceptualization of state-religion relations that avoids identifications of the state with any particular religion and ideology. Thispaper will briefly examine the genealogy of these two competing claims, and it will also highlight the arguments and counter-arguments of the representative scholars of bothclaims.


Download data is not yet available.


Adams, Charles, Islam and Modernism in Egypt (OxfordUniversity Press, 1933) p. 261

al-Qardawi, Yusuf,Min Fiqh al-Dawlah fi al-Islam (Cairo; Beirut: Dar al-Shuruq, 1997), p. 32. Also quoted in Belkeziz, The state in contemporary Islamic Thought, p. 127

al-Qardawi, Yusuf,al-Ṣaḥwah al-Islamiyah (Cairo: Dar al-Ṣaḥwah, 1988), p. 188 also quoted in Abdelilah,The State in Contemporary Islamic Thought: A historical survey of the major Muslim Political Thinkers of the modern era,(Bloomsbury Publishing, 2009)p.127

Al-Tahir ibn, Mohammad ‘Ashoor, Naqd ‘IlmyLikitab Al-Islam Wa Usool Al-Hukm(Cairo: Maktaba al-Salafiyya, 1925), 11

Amara, Mohammad, ‘Ma’raka Al-Islam Wa Usool Al-Hukm (Cairo: Dar al-Sharook,1997) p. 171

An-Na'im,Abdullahi,Islam and the Secular state: Negotiating the Future of Shariah (Harvard University Press, 2008)pp.2-3

Anjum, Ovamir,“who wants caliphate”,yaqeen Institute for IslamicResearch(oct,2019)p.3

Ayoob, Mohammed, "Political Islam: image and reality." World Policy Journal 21, no. 3 (2004):p.2

Bayat, Asef, Making Islam Democratic: Social Movements and the Post-Islamist Turn (Stanford: Stanford University Press,2007) p.11

Belkeziz, Abdelilah, The State in Contemporary Islamic Thought: A historical survey of the major Muslim Political Thinkers of the modern era.123

Berween,Mohamed, "Al-wathiqa: The first Islamic state constitution." Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs 23, no. 1 (2003): 103-120

El-Affendi,Esposito, and Tamimi. "Rationality of politics and politics of rationality." Sciences 29, no. 4 (2000): 63-86.

Esposito,John L,Voices of Resurgent Islam. (Newyork: Oxford University Press, 1983)p.180

Ghamidi Javed, “The Rule of an Islamic Government”, Renaissance, November 2011; (; content.aspx?id=1289Accessed 05/10/2016.

Ghamidi Javed,Islam: A Comprehensive Introduction. English translation of Meezanby ShehzadSaleem(Lahore: Al-Mawrid,2010),p.451

Ismael, Tariq and Jacqueline Ismael, Government and Politics in Islam, (New Delhi: CBS Publishers & Distributers, 1991)p.25

Iqbal, Muhammad,Kulliyat-e-Iqbal, (Bang-e-Dara, ,غره شوال یا ہلال عیدp. 193) (Lahore: Iqbal Academy Pakistan, 1990), p. 209

Iqbal, Muhammad,The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam, 2nded., (Lahore: Iqbal Academy Pakistan and the Institute of Islamic Culture,1986), p.142.

Javed Ahmad Ghamidi,Islam and the State: A Counter Narrative. It is Originally a lecture later on it was rendered into English by Shazadsaleem, (Lahore:Al Mawrid,2016)

Jung, Dietrich. "Islam and Politics: A Fixed Relationship." Critique: Critical Middle Eastern Studies 16.1 (2007): 19-35.

Mahmood, Saba “Secularism, Hermeneutics, and Empire: The Politics of Islamic Reformation.” Public Culture (2006) Volume 18, Issue 2; 326-7.

Maududi, Sayyid,Political Theory of Islam 3rd ed., (Delhi: MarkaziMaktabaIslami,2019), pp.20-32

Moten, Abdul Rashid,Political Science: An Islamic Perspective. (Newyork: Palgrave Macmillan, 1996)p.96

Raziq, Ali Abdul “Al-Islaam Wa Usool Al-Hukm,” in Al-Islaam Wa Usool Al-Hukm—Darasa Wa Watha’iq, ed., Mohammad ‘Amara (Beirut: Al-Mua’sasa al-Arabiyya lial-darasat wa al-nashr, 1972)

Scott, James, seeing like a state: How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed. (New Heaven: Yale University Press, 1998), p.98

Waliullah, Shah,Izalah al-Khilafa’, vol. I p. 28 as Qouted in Mahmood A. Ghazi, Studies in the Political and Constitutional Thought of Islam, (Lahore: National Book House, 1992),pp.27.239

Wan Saiful Wan Jan’s “Preface” in Abdelwahab El-Affendi, Who Needs an Islamic State? 2nd ed., (UK: Malaysia Think Tank London, 2008), p. 14




How to Cite

Showkat Ahmad Wagay (2023) “Muslim Contestations over Islam and the State Relationship: A Critical Appraisal”, al-Afkar, Journal For Islamic Studies, 6(4), pp. 1–13. doi: 10.31943/afkarjournal.v6i4.659.